A famend Boston-area fertility physician is going through a federal lawsuit from a former affected person who alleges he secretly impregnated her together with his personal sperm throughout a synthetic insemination process a long time in the past
In a lawsuit filed Wednesday in Boston federal court docket, Maine resident Sarah Depoian defined that she and her husband went to Dr. Merle Berger — the now-retired co-founder of Boston IVF — in 1980 for assist getting pregnant. In line with the lawsuit, Berger “promised to carry out an insemination utilizing the sperm of a medical resident who resembled [Depoian’s] husband, who didn’t know her, and whom she didn’t know.”
As an alternative, the physician secretly substituted his personal sperm, Depoian’s lawyer alleged throughout a information convention Wednesday.
“He did so with out her consent and in opposition to her needs,” mentioned Peiffer Wolf associate Adam Wolf. “Some folks name this horrific act medical rape. However no matter what you name it, Dr. Berger’s heinous and intentional misconduct is unethical, unacceptable, and illegal.”
Depoian’s daughter, Carolyn Bester, was born in January 1981.
Talking to reporters, Bester mentioned she discovered the reality about her parentage earlier this 12 months, after buying DNA testing kits from Ancestry.com and 23andMe. Amongst her DNA matches have been Berger’s granddaughter and second cousin, she mentioned.
“I spoke to one in every of them, and I began piecing all of it collectively,” Bester mentioned. “To say I used to be shocked once I figured this out could be an excessive understatement. It seems like actuality has shifted.”
Berger’s lawyer, Ian Pinta of Todd & Weld, disputed the lawsuit’s claims in a press release on the physician’s behalf: “The allegations, which have modified repeatedly within the six months because the plaintiff’s lawyer first contacted Dr. Berger, haven’t any authorized or factual benefit, and will probably be disproven in court docket.”
But Wolf contended that Berger didn’t deny the allegations when initially confronted. He asserted that Depoian’s story has been constant from the beginning and mentioned they look ahead to proving their case.
Who’s Dr. Merle Berger?
The allegations in Depoian’s lawsuit predate the 1986 founding of Boston IVF, a community of fertility clinics with 10 places in Massachusetts and several other extra in Maine, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, New York, and Indiana. Boston.com has reached out to Boston IVF for touch upon the lawsuit.
Berger, who has properties in Boston and on Martha’s Winery, is a former professor at Harvard Medical College and the creator of the 2020 guide “Conception: A Fertility Physician’s Memoir.” Upon Berger’s retirement that 12 months, Boston IVF famous in a now-archived weblog publish that the physician’s profession is “primarily the historical past of IVF in America.”
Pinta described Berger as a “pioneer” within the area of medical fertility who helped 1000’s of households have youngsters over the course of half a century.
“He’s broadly recognized for his sensitivity to the emotional anguish of the ladies who got here to him for assist conceiving,” Pinta mentioned. “The allegations concern occasions from over 40 years in the past, within the early days of synthetic insemination. At a time earlier than sperm banks and IVF, it was dramatically totally different from modern-day fertility remedy.”
As mail-order genetic testing kits have risen in reputation, there have been quite a lot of high-profile circumstances the place docs have been accused of inseminating sufferers utilizing their very own sperm. For instance, the 2022 Netflix documentary “Our Father” tells the story of Indiana fertility specialist Dr. Donald Cline, who fathered not less than 94 youngsters with out disclosing himself because the sperm donor.
Physician’s alleged acts have been an ‘excessive violation,’ former affected person says
Depoian mentioned she and her husband “totally trusted” Berger after they sought his assist conceiving.
“It’s laborious to think about not trusting your individual physician,” she instructed reporters Wednesday. “We by no means dreamt he would abuse his place of belief and perpetrate this excessive violation.”
She mentioned having her daughter by her facet has given her the energy to return ahead together with her story.
“I’m struggling to course of it, however this by no means, ever will change the love we now have for our daughter, Carolyn,” Depoian mentioned. “If something, this has lit a hearth in me to struggle for her and some other unsuspecting sufferer, whether or not by Dr. Berger or one other fertility physician.”
Wolf mentioned the brand new allegations elevate questions on whether or not Berger may need secretly used his personal sperm to inseminate different sufferers. He additionally recommended that Bester may file a lawsuit of her personal in opposition to the doctor sooner or later sooner or later.
Bester, who lives in New Jersey, cited her 5-year-old son as one motive she and her mom are in search of accountability in court docket.
“I would like to have the ability to look my son within the eye and inform him that we stood up for one thing that was improper that occurred in our household,” she mentioned.
Keep updated on all the most recent information from Boston.com