July 16, 2024


On Wednesday, the Monica’s Trattoria proprietor was ordered held with out bail till at the very least 2024, after an arraignment in Suffolk Superior Court docket the day earlier than, based on the Suffolk County District Lawyer’s Workplace.

North Finish restaurateur Patrick Mendoza attends a dangerousness listening to in Boston Municipal Court docket on Wednesday, July 26, 2023. Libby O’Neill / Pool

North Finish restaurant proprietor Patrick Mendoza has been ordered held with out bail till at the very least Might 2024 as he awaits trial for allegedly attempting to shoot and kill a person exterior Fashionable Pastry who he’s been feuding with for years.

Patrick Mendoza, 54, proprietor of Monica’s Trattoria, is dealing with prices in reference to a July 12 capturing within the North Finish. – Boston Police Division

The 54-year-old Boston resident pleaded not responsible to prices associated to the July incident throughout his arraignment in Suffolk Superior Court docket Tuesday, based on courtroom information. A dangerousness listening to was held the identical day, and on Wednesday, a choose granted prosecutors’ request to maintain him detained for at the very least six extra months.

“That is an acceptable ruling given the acute hazard of Mr. Mendoza’s actions, which occurred in one of many metropolis’s busiest areas and on considered one of its busiest streets,” Suffolk County District Lawyer Kevin Hayden reportedly stated in an announcement.

Mendoza, who co-own’s Monica’s Trattoria on Prince Road, was indicted in late September on prices of armed assault with intent to homicide, tried assault and battery with a firearm, and three different firearm offenses.

What occurred in July, based on authorities

A bullet gap, proper, is seen within the entrance window of Fashionable Pastry on Hanover Road the day after the capturing.

In accordance with the police report, the capturing occurred July 12 round 11 p.m. at 257 Hanover St. — Fashionable Pastry’s deal with. The sufferer instructed police that Mendoza got here as much as him and shouted, “I’m gonna kill you [expletive]! It’s going to be fast!”

Mendoza then allegedly shot on the sufferer earlier than leaving the scene, based on courtroom paperwork. The police report stated the sufferer was in a position to duck behind a automobile and efficiently evade the bullets. Nobody was damage, however the capturing left a bullet gap in Fashionable Pastry’s entrance window.

Reportedly, the meant sufferer was Rocco Giovenello, who lives above Fashionable Pastry and is talked about in courtroom paperwork associated to the case. He beforehand instructed native information retailers he’s been feuding with Mendoza and his brother, Frank Mendoza, for years.

Safety video from the scene mirrors the occasions described in official paperwork. Moreover, courtroom paperwork say police recovered a palm print from a automobile that the shooter might be seen touching in video footage of the capturing. That palm print allegedly matched Mendoza’s.

After the capturing, Mendoza allegedly went on the run from police. A warrant for his arrest on prices associated to the capturing was then issued, and a few week later, he turned himself in to police in Falmouth.

Police Stories About Patrick Mendoza by Susannah Sudborough on Scribd

Why Mendoza probably gained’t be launched earlier than trial

Up to now, Mendoza has been held with out bail as a result of judges have deemed him a hazard to others. His high-profile protection legal professional, Rosemary Scapicchio, has been attempting to persuade the courtroom that he ought to have some kind of bail choice in order that he doesn’t stay in jail till his trial, which is at the very least months away.

In accordance with the Boston Herald, through the arraignment Tuesday, Scapicchio argued that prosecutors hadn’t even confirmed that Mendoza had fired a gun.

“The commonwealth has not introduced anybody, not even a police officer, to speak about rumour for an identification,” she reportedly argued. “His liberty is at stake proper now, and the concept the commonwealth can, by doc alone, take away somebody’s liberty is opposite to the Structure.”

However Chris Dearborn, a Suffolk College Regulation Faculty professor, says that after a defendant is held with out bail, it turns into tough for the protection to get them launched, as every subsequent ruling carries inertia.

“Given the general public nature of the case and given the severity of the costs, not essentially guilt or innocence, I believe it’s going to be an uphill battle,” he stated.

What’s subsequent for Patrick Mendoza

The time between arraignment and trial is often a 12 months, Dearborn stated. Given the seriousness of the costs, he thinks the case will go to trial.

If this occurs, a win for the prosecution could be a responsible verdict on all prices, or at the very least on essentially the most severe prices, Dearborn stated. For the protection, many small victories are potential, together with getting essentially the most severe prices towards Mendoza diminished, dismissed, or acquitted.

“Generally it’s about chipping away and successful smaller battles slightly than successful the last word battle,” he stated.

With this many prices, it could be tough to persuade a jury to acquit Mendoza of each cost, the professor stated. Even so, he cautioned to not make huge assumptions concerning the case or Mendoza, particularly given his lawyer’s accolades.

A pretrial listening to for this case has been scheduled for Dec. 21, however courtroom information present that Mendoza is due in courtroom for proceedings concerning different open circumstances.

The courtroom remains to be within the strategy of deciding whether or not Mendoza violated bail situations associated to a December 2022 assault and battery conviction. The Herald stories that Giovenello was the sufferer on this case as properly.

Moreover, a trial throughout which the jury will resolve if Mendoza is responsible of assault and battery and larceny is scheduled to start Dec. 7.